Friday, September 3, 2010

Remembering Sergeant Paul Starzyk

Remembrance Event for Sergeant Paul A. Starzyk on Monday, September 6, 2010

Martinez Police Department will host a public remembrance to honor Sgt. Paul A. Starzyk, who was killed in the line of duty, September 6, 2008

Tentative Schedule for September 6, 2010
7:00 AM- Uniformed personnel form up in front of the fountain near the flag pole.

7:10 AM - Honor Guard to present flag and memorial flag at half staff in front of City Hall

8:00-11:00 AM - Council Chambers open to public for public memorial; small guided tours of the memorial wall inside the police department

11:35 AM - Police Chief's comments

1139:17 AM - Moment of silence
"The wicked flee when no man pursueth: but the righteous are as bold as a lion."- Proverbs 28:1

Thursday, September 2, 2010

"You are not alone"

The dream team from the Behavioral Health Kaizen is checking back in at today's CCRMC Improvement Academy. They've formed a rapid response (for lack of a better term) called the "You Are Not Alone" (YANA)Team. The team's aim is to ease the collateral suffering experienced by those close to major medical and psychological crisis. Team members are be trained in peer to peer crisis management, community resources, and organizational fluency to allow facilitation of visiting and to offer immediate support to the family and friends of our patients. Codes are predicted to last approximately 15 - 20 minutes for the purpose of assisting families in activating their own support systems for longer term support, orient them to the medical center and/or unit, and the provision of resources (local food, hotels, and support groups/crisis lines). The YANA design team plans to also work w/ medical center volunteers to create "comfort packs" for both children and adults (consisting off nonperishable food & water, and entertainment such as newspapers and activities for children).

Please join your colleagues and hear of the work they've been doing to ensure that when facing a crisis "you are not alone' at CCRMC.


Additionally: Jon Stanger continues his noon conference ethics discussions. Today Jon will present "Taking Suffering Seriously."

I hope you're seeing a theme here. and I hope you join today's discussions.

My best,
Anna

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

CCRMC Improvement Academy: Deming's System Of Profound Knowledge Session One

"We have learned to live in a world of mistakes and defective products as if they were necessary to life. It is time to adopt a new philosophy...." -W. Edwards Deming
REMINDER:
CCRMC's Improvement Academy meets Thursday August 26th at 9:00 AM in Building One, Conference Room One. I will present an overview of W. Edwards Deming's System of Profound Knowledge.

This will be the first of a series of dedicated learning sessions on Deming's System of Profound Knowledge and transformation.

Please join us.
Anna

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

More on Forgiveness

Posted by Jon Stanger, MD

[Five years ago, in the wake of a troubling case involving delayed diagnosis, a subgroup of our Ethics Committee was convened to consider and make recommendations for appropriate management of adverse patient outcomes and medical error within our system. The Subcommittee’s findings and recommendations led directly to the formation of our current Medical Error and Adverse Outcome (MEAO) Committee. I invite you read the final “Report of the Subcommittee on Disclosure of Medical Error.” It can be found in the “Ethics” folder on the desktop of any computer in our system, within the subfolder “3.0 – Policies and Reports,” and under the heading “Medical Error Disclosure Subcommittee Report.”]

Kudos to our CEO for having the courage, once again, to engage a very complex and critically important topic – without presuming to have all the answers. This time Anna has invited us to consider the painful reality of error within our professional practice and the prospect for forgiveness. Anna’s comments and references urge us to look beyond formal responses and institutional structures, to consider the personal, spiritual meaning of harmful error brought about by good people while trying to help others - and the potential for healing afforded by forgiveness.

Forgiveness is a tricky business and, I believe, it is important to resist facile formulations. Two possible conceptual traps in considering forgiveness I would call “cheap forgiveness” and “forgiveness denied.”

“Cheap forgiveness” comes into play when we see forgiveness as something we are entitled to. The reasoning goes something like this:

Medicine is a risky business from the outset. The patient comes to us for help and we do our best, but there can be no guarantees. Even in the best of circumstances, complications and mistakes are liable to occur. It is unreasonable for the patient and family to hold us morally or legally accountable for these unintended consequences... They owe us forgiveness.

It’s not that there isn’t some validity to this line of reasoning. Indeed, I think this is a powerful rebuttal to the current system of medical malpractice liability in our country. The error here is that this depiction, just like the legalistic remedy it seeks to counter, reduces a complex human reality – the specter of a vulnerable patient coming to harm at the hands of those trusted with his/her care – to a simplistic calculus of rights and obligations. This is a demand for “cheap forgiveness.“

Forgiveness – at least the kind of forgiveness that has a potential to heal – cannot be demanded or won as matter of rights or entitlement. Forgiveness is never an obligation of the aggrieved. It must be freely given, if it is to be authentic. And it must take account of the human dimensions and relational realities of the situation – realities like suffering, guilt, and perceived betrayal of trust. It must be earned.

What are the elements of “earning” this kind of forgiveness? Anna refers us to the wise counsel of the Reverend Victor Carpenter on the occasion of honoring Nelson Mandela at Harvard University. In this speech, Rev. Carpenter alludes to the work of Archbishop Desmond Tutu and the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa. During my years in seminary at the Graduate Theological Union, I had the opportunity to study Tutu’s Ubuntu theology and the history of the T & R Commission in some depth. Principles pertaining to forgiveness and reconciliation that have emerged from international experiences like that of South Africa include:

· Never ignore or trivialize the victim’s suffering.

· Causes must be uncovered and confronted.

· Repentance comes from the perpetrator, but reconciliation and forgiveness must come from the victim.

· Reconciliation involves construction of a new narrative of meaning that acknowledges the trauma while recognizing the humanity of the offending party and daring to trust and commit to relationship again.

· Forgiveness and reconciliation are processes that often take time.

I don’t think that it’s a stretch to see the relevance of these principles to our consideration of forgiveness and reconciliation in the setting of medical error. Here as well, forgiveness of the patient or family cannot be presumed, and reconciliation has certain prerequisites to re-establish the trust required for a therapeutic relationship. “Earning” reconciliation in the medical setting requires:

· Prompt discovery and honest disclosure of causes, to the extent possible.

· Sincere expression of regret or apology.

· Time taken to answer questions and to listen to the patient’s story.

· Demonstrable commitment to learn from the error and to prevent future recurrences.

Any expectation of forgiveness or reconciliation that side steps these elements of the process would be evidence of “cheap forgiveness.”

The second trap of forgiveness I call “forgiveness denied.” “Forgiveness denied” applies when the clinician, having taken the steps to facilitate reconciliation, remains unable to learn from the mishap and move ahead without the patient’s explicit forgiveness – which may not be forthcoming.

This concept raises the question, “Whose forgiveness am I seeking?” I would argue that there is not a single answer to this query. Certainly, our first reaction must be to say that we are seeking (or hoping to earn) the forgiveness of the patient and/or family. I have seen the transformative, healing power of this experience – when the care-giver’s honesty, sincere expression of regret, and demonstrated commitment to prevent future recurrences are met by acceptance, understanding, and forgiveness on the part of the patient and family. No one who has been involved in such a case will ever question the healing power of the experience.

However, I have also seen any number of instances in which the most earnest efforts of the professional are not followed by any expression of forgiveness by the patient. Here again, I think we are wise to avoid falling back into the trap of “cheap forgiveness” that assumes we are entitled to such a response. So, is the dedicated professional in such a circumstance left to merely hope for some future softening of the patient’s disposition? To a certain extent, yes – while maintaining compassionate contact and openness to being with the patient through the process.

But there is more to the dynamic of forgiveness than seeking absolution from the patient or family. Indeed, I believe that the primary moral valence of any expression of forgiveness by the patient is as an indication of healing of the patient himself. This is not to say that the effect on the caregiver is not profound – it certainly is. When the family says, “We forgive you,” the physician is granted permission … to what? To forgive herself.

This gets us back to the question I raised earlier, “Whose forgiveness am I seeking?” and my suggestion that “the patient’s or family’s” may not be the only answer. It is critically important to recognize that clinicians also suffer in these cases. The emotional toll upon clinicians involved in cases of medical error can be devastating. And the all-too-common “shame and blame” response has the potential for personal and professional destruction, even as it obstructs constructive efforts to help this, and future, patients.

When we compassionately consider the position of the care-provider, as well as the individualized reality of the patient’s response, it becomes unreasonable to require the patient’s forgiveness before the clinician can find some peace in the wake of a mistake. Provided careful attention has been paid to the elements of earning reconciliation as discussed above, we must guard against dependence upon “forgiveness denied” just as we have rejected the facile expectations of “cheap forgiveness.” In a very important sense, then, another legitimate answer to the question, “Whose forgiveness am I seeking?” may be “my own”, or for those with a religious faith orientation, “God’s.”

Let me close this overly long commentary by strongly recommending two films. The first is “Long Night’s Journey Into Day,” a moving documentary of the Truth and Reconciliation process in South Africa.

My second recommendation is Ingmar Bergman’s masterpiece “Wild Strawberries.” This film is a harsh, but ultimately warm and very human story of an elderly physician who has been chosen to receive an honorary degree in recognition of his 50 years of service. During his lengthy road trip to the site where he will receive his award, Dr. Borg reflects on his life course, both personal and professional, and strives to come to terms with the realization of his own shortcomings. His sleep is disrupted by a dramatic nightmare in which he is called into a medical lecture hall to take a clinical examination in front of a large audience. Filled with self-doubt, he is grilled by the examining professor in the same “callous, selfish, and ruthless” manner that he has adopted toward his own students over the years. Now in the role of student himself, he is unable even to focus the microscope for identification of a bacterium on a slide. His diagnosis of a patient’s clinical condition is egregiously wrong. And, in the final question of the exam, he is asked to complete the sentence, “The first duty of the physician is … …” His mind is a blank. He can think of nothing.

Final grade – “Incompetent.”

We think we know the answer, don’t we? I thought I did. You… we… are wrong. The answer in the film? “The first duty of the physician is … … to ask forgiveness.”

Sunday, August 22, 2010

A Culture of Safety: Forgiving

“The day is committed to error and floundering; success and achievement are matters of long range” ~ Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

I've been thinking about the "Safety Incident Detection and Response System Optimization" efforts and our culture. In reading about cultures in ultra-safe industry (airlines, nuclear power, European railways), as opposed to health care which is not considered to be, I have found that a relentless focus on learning and moving beyond the need to blame and the need for redemption seems to be a system attribute in each these industries. I should add that many others are thinking about this as well.

Thankfully, courageous leaders such as Lucian Leape, Don Berwick, Jim Conway, Maureen Bisognano and many more have advanced the discussions about how we respond to medical error and system failures into mainstream discussions and media publications. Here is a recent article the NY Times on disclosing medical error and apology. The Executive Director of Chugachmiut, Inc., an Alaska Native Tribal consortium recently posted in his blog "Lean in Alaska" Pointing Fingers, where he discusses a "no blame, no shame" culture. He points to W Edwards Deming's System of Profound Knowledge and Deming's focus on pride and joy in work. A simple Google query will yield thousands of related links on error, just culture, culture of safety, apology, blame, bad apple versus system response etc. There is no dearth of reading if you're interested.

A request for help. How do we move from blaming to forgiving?

I am not trying to minimize how complicated this is. To the contrary, I believe that too often this complex socio/cultural concept is oversimplified. The term "transparency" is tossed about as if it comes easy and as if it will save us. Please don't misunderstand, I am in favor of transparency. Yet I do believe there is a tension between transparency and for lack of a better term, a "need to know." There is a tension between an inclusive and democratic process and an autocratic process. Leading the system and providing service within it is a complex and humbling undertaking. I look to the words of one of the greatest change agents who ever lived, W. Edwards Deming who said, "All transformation begins with the individual." If we are to create safe, fair and just culture; if we are to create a culture of continuous improvement, we must begin with ourselves. With each new day and each new challenge we will continue to discover that those who came before us carried heavy burdens for us all. It's our turn now. We are here to make a new world.

I am not asking anyone to be perfect. I ask that we help each other and provide service to our community in the most respectful way possible. I don't pretend to have all the answers. I ask that we work together to lead our system forward and to recognize that sometimes, like those people we are here to support in carrying out our shared mission, we will make mistakes.

It's important that we all work together. It's important that we all learn together. That means all of us. Those we are here to serve are depending on us getting this right. We must learn to work through system failures and to work through mistakes.

I am not suggesting we forget harm or look away from difficult situations. I am suggesting we learn to forgive and not let it divide us as looking for blame will. I am not suggesting we be complacent in any way. I am asking that we draw on courage. Drawing on the same humility we require as leaders of our great health system, we must not allow mistakes to create permanent barriers between us. There will be times we must look beyond the mistakes of others and remember to be grateful they are participating. To better understand what I am saying I offer the speech Victor H. Carpenter presented at Harvard when Nelson Mandela was honored there. Please take a moment to read his very brief but powerful remarks on "Forgiveness: The Mandela Principle" and I believe you will understand what I am trying to say to you.

Change is here. With that, all that is possible lies before us.

Now, we move forward.
Anna

Saturday, August 21, 2010

Thanks to everyone who posted in my absence. The posts and comments are fantastic.

I'm delighted to tell you that some of the guests have agreed to come back from time to time.

Something wonderful to look forward to!

Anna

Friday, August 20, 2010

Upcoming changes in our system

Posted by Tess O'Riva, CCRMC Communications Director

In last Monday's message to staff , Dr. William Walker, Health Services Director, described some of the ways he is preparing Health Services to best meet the challenges and opportunities within Health Care Reform.

His message is below.
"In recent Director’s Report messages, I described what health reform under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and the California Medi-Cal waiver means to Health Services and the patients we serve. As provisions of the Act and new requirements of the waiver – a bridge to health reform’s complete roll-out – are unveiling, I continue to realize that in order to prepare ourselves to meet the challenges that are before us now and into 2014, significant changes in our system, particularly the service delivery side of our organization and our leadership structure, must begin.

The new legislation offers many opportunities for demonstration projects and pilot programs, which would be well suited to our system. There are also new requirements and incentives for integration across our various Divisions. With this in mind, I have asked Dianne Dunn-Bowie to move to a new role as Executive Director, Health Services Integration and Governmental Relations. Dianne, with her many years of experience in all aspects of health care, will help us to strengthen key political relationships, build new community partnerships and develop new models of service integration.

We must move quickly to seamless and safe handoffs of patient care between our inpatient and outpatient systems. We must improve access to primary care and specialty services and develop more effective interactions between inpatient and outpatient staff. We must develop improved case management and care coordination functions. I have concluded that this will not happen within the current structure of separate Divisions. I am therefore combining Ambulatory Care and the Medical Center into a single Division under CEO Anna Roth effective September 1, 2010.

This past year has been an unprecedented year of change at CCRMC. In the last twelve months all but one executive leadership position has turned over as leaders retired after a long and rewarding career at CCHS. Several months ago, CCRMC CEO Anna Roth began redesigning a number of her departments, including safety and performance improvement, professional development, detention health and emergency services, behavioral health, perioperative services, and inpatient medicine. In addition to the ongoing operational redesign efforts, Anna has introduced initiatives to build internal capacity to grow and continually improve.

Also on September 1, 2010, Dr. Chris Farnitano, Chair of our Family Medicine Department, will move into a management Medical Director position with primary responsibility for leading the development of new models of team-based care, patient-centered medical homes, improved patient flow and timely access to outpatient care. Our goal is to be a national model for improved chronic disease benchmarks. Dr. Farnitano will also be intimately involved in the system changes necessary for the installation of our Electronic Medical Record over the next couple of years. We are also currently recruiting to hire a Chief Operations Officer for the Hospital and Health Centers. Reporting relationships for this new structure are now being developed.

In the weeks, months and years ahead we have much work to do. As we continue to learn more about the specifics of health reform, I anticipate that there will be additional restructuring. Some of our efforts will be successful and others will need to be tweaked or rethought. This will be an exciting time for all of us.

The dedication we have to serving the community and to supporting each other makes us a model for the new American system of health care. We have made great strides over the past decades to develop a system that puts the patient/consumer/client first and provides the kind of services that care for the whole patient. I believe that with the dedication and commitment of all of you, we will successfully make the system changes necessary and meet the challenges that are before us."

Putting Contra Costa Health Services at the forefront of Health Care Reform is both exciting and inspiring. I share Dr. Walker's belief that our system is poised to change the way health care is delivered and be a model for the nation, not only because of our unique structure, but because of the people we work with. I can't wait!

Tess O'Riva

CCRMC Communications Director